New Case Ruling Shows the Importance of Proper Action Before Filing a Lawsuit
|
|
The Garden-Aire Village South Condominium Association recently learned the hard way that failure to comply with certain pre-requisites can thwart efforts to address a claim. This association filed a lawsuit against its insurance company, QBE Insurance Corporation, in October of 2010 - shortly before five (5) years from Hurricane Wilma. The association requested the court to:
|
The lawsuit was filed as an action for declaratory judgment. There are both state and federal procedures available for someone to obtain a declaratory judgment from a court when there is a uncertainty involving differing interpretations of rights or obligations pursuant to a contract, statute or other legal documents. In Florida this process is addressed in Chapter 86 of the Florida Statutes. Section 86.021, Florida Statutes says: "Power to construe.—Any person claiming to be interested or who may be in doubt about his or her rights under a deed, will, contract, or other article, memorandum, or instrument in writing or whose rights, status, or other equitable or legal relations are affected by a statute, or any regulation made under statutory authority, or by municipal ordinance, contract, deed, will, franchise, or other article, memorandum, or instrument in writing may have determined any question of construction or validity arising under such statute, regulation, municipal ordinance, contract, deed, will, franchise, or other article, memorandum, or instrument in writing, or any part thereof, and obtain a declaration of rights, status, or other equitable or legal relations thereunder." The Federal laws are slightly different. Federal law requires the party filing the action to show they have been harmed or are facing imminent harm as a result of the differences in interpretation or analysis of the rights and obligations of the parties. In this case the association couldn't show there was an actual controversy at the time it filed the lawsuit. The lawsuit alleged that QBE didn't "consider the windows and sliding glass doors". It also alleged that QBE "has frequently taken the position in the past that windows and sliding glass doors are not covered", but QBE did not issue that statement or position with respect to the Garden-Aire claim as it wasn't forced to do so by actions on the part of the association. Since the insurance carrier didn't formally deny a claim for coverage of windows and sliding glass doors before the lawsuit was file, the court dismissed the association's claim. [See Garden-Aire Village South Condominium Association, Inc. vs. QBE Insurance Corporation, Case No. 10-6195-CIV-DIMITROULEAS] The court likewise dismissed the second portion of the claim, finding that the association didn't provide QBE with the reasonable opportunity to evaluate the damages alleged in the association's supplemental claim. The association demanded an appraisal the day after it filed its lawsuit when it should have submitted evidence of the damages beforehand. Since a ruling on the the third count depends upon a ruling in a case already pending before the Florida Supreme Court, that portion of the lawsuit was put on hold by agreement of the parties and the court itself. Dismissal of the first two counts is quite significant. The court mentioned the fact that some of the association's claims may be time-barred as a result of the Statute of Limitations. The lesson here is that you can't skip steps when it comes to litigation. If there are pre-requisites to filing suit, work with counsel to ensure they are met (or waived) beforehand. |
|
.jpg)
The
In anticipation of Friday's webinar, here is the first in our two-part checklists for community associations.



Large Insurance Bill Addresses Fees & Advertising by Public Adjusters, Deadlines for Filing Windstorm/Hurricane Related Claims, Policy Terms and Payouts by Carriers.