Florida Condo & HOA Legal Blog : Florida Condo Lawyer & Attorney : Becker & Poliakoff Law Firm : Condominium & HOA Law Blog

On August 17, 2009, the Task Force On Residential Mortgage Foreclosure, created by the Florida Supreme Court, issued its final report on the "foreclosure crisis" affecting condominium and homeowners' associations throughout the state.

The full report can be viewed at http://www.floridasupremecourt.org/pub_info/documents/Filed_08-17-2009_Foreclosure_Final_Report.pdf

The following quote, taken directly from the report, succinctly sums up what community associations are presently dealing with. Here is what the Task Force said:  

 

Picture this: the biggest road out of town. Now imagine it is rush hour. In a thunderstorm. Add that it also a hurricane evacuation. A lane is closed due to construction delayed by budget impacts. Imagine the traffic jam.

The clearest description of the impact of the foreclosure crisis and the following recession on Florida's courts can be summarized by that picture. Imagine every car a case. The General Jurisdiction Courts of our State have a certain amount of judicial infrastructure, just like there is a certain amount of room on the road. There is a certain capacity of judges, of court staff, of clerks, of filing space, of hearing time, or courtrooms, even of hours in the day. Year in, year out, that capacity flexes with the caseload traffic to afford reasonable, prompt, efficient and fair justice.

The enormous increase in foreclosure filings has overwhelmed those resources in many circuits and represents a traffic jam that the infrastructure cannot meet in a timely and efficient manner without support and traffic management.

I would add to the above quote that at a time when the evacuation route is jam-packed with cars, imagine further that more and more roads are continuing to be closed as the traffic jam gets worse. Unfortunately, that's the scenario facing our courts when the Legislature insists on cutting funding of the courts. The largest expense of the court system is in personnel, so in a time of burgeoning foreclosure caseloads, the courts are actually being forced to lay off staff. Too many foreclosure cases and not enough people to handle them. Indeed, we hear the daily mantra from frustrated clients asking what is taking so long with these cases? Well, truly, this is a "perfect storm." The storm has caused a huge backlog in the court system which significantly delays the time it takes to complete a foreclosure lawsuit.

All is not lost, however. Associations need not sit idle on the sidelines once a mortgage foreclosure action is filed and seems to stall. Directors need to monitor these cases and can often, with the assistance of counsel, file motions with the court to force banks to either foreclose or pay assessments, ask for case management conferences where the court can set some deadlines for action, or the association might even notice the case for trial, which will force the bank to move forward. In fact, this tactic is working. Several judges in districts throughout the state have entered Orders requiring banks to take some action with their foreclosure cases and in some instances, pay assessments to the association during the pendency of the foreclosure.

• Email This
• Print
• Comments
• Trackbacks
• Share Link

The Florida Consumer Collection Practices Act Prohibits Associations From Posting Delinquency Lists and Taking Other Actions to Collect Assessments and Maintenance Fees.

 There have been a number of newspaper articles explaining actions taken by community association boards and managers to collect delinquent assessments.  The Miami Herald reported that some associations post lists of the names of the owners behind on their fees and others deny security access devices to tenants of delinquent owners.  

The Wall Street Journal reported that some associations were taking control of the unoccupied units and renting them on a short term basis until the bank foreclosed.  

While we are all familiar with the idiom "drastic times call for drastic measures",  community leaders and property managers should understand that Florida law prohibits unfair or abusive tactics with regard to debt collection, including the collection of assessments.   Although the prohibitions in the Federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act do not apply to the person or entity owed the debt (the 'creditor', which in this case is the Association), both community associations and their managing agents are responsible for compliance with the Florida Laws.

Among other practices, Section 559.72, Florida Statutes, prohibits the following:

• Use of profane, obscene, vulgar, or willfully abusive language in communicating with a debtor or any member of his or her family;
   
• Communication with a debtor under the guise of an attorney by using the stationary of an attorney or forms or instruments which only attorneys are authorized to prepare;
   
• Orally communicating with a debtor in such a manner as to give the false impression or appearance that such person is associated with an attorney;
   
• Publishing or posting, threatening to publish or post, or causing to be published or posted before the general public individual names or any list of names of debtors, commonly know as a deadbeat list, for the purpose of enforcing or attempting to enforce collection of consumer debts;
   
• Mailing any communication to a debtor in an envelope or postcard with words typed, written, or printed n the outside of the envelope or postcard calculated to embarrass the debtor. An example of this would be an envelope addressed to “Deadbeat, Jane Doe” or “Deadbeat, John Doe”;
   
• Communicating with the debtor between the hours of 9 p.m. and 8 a.m. without the prior written consent of the debtor.

While every association must be diligent with its collection efforts, those efforts must be in compliance with legal and ethical standards.

On the other hand, the Florida Courts are cognizant of the problem and have allowed Associations to have receivers appointed for the purposes of collecting rent from tenants when the owners of those units are facing foreclosure as a result of non-payment of assessments.  Remember to check this site in the future for more information about proactive methods to collect assessments.

• Email This
• Print
• Comments (18)
• Trackbacks (1)
• Share Link

As naïve as it sounds, foreclosure is business, not personal. There are some fundamental questions that need to be asked to curb the passion and focus the decisions on the economics of business.  In truth, the Association does not want the foreclosure but rather what results from it, the sale. So we need both the foreclosure and the sale for the Association to be able to get the money it is owed.

Let’s talk a bit about whether the Association should foreclose. Given the past history of property values the foreclosure decision was simple. The difference in the amount of the market value and mortgaged value left significant excess available to settle the assessments from the foreclosure action at the sale. In the current environment of depressed market values, significant portions of the properties in arrears on assessments also have significant mortgages, putting the Association in a disadvantaged position. The disadvantage is lack of equity to foreclose against; making recovery of assessments a bit more complicated and sometimes even fruitless.

The above has to be balanced against the fact that the assessments are the lifeblood of the community to maintain, beautify, and provide the amenities to the members.  All members are required to support the community through the payments of assessments. Non-paying members should not be allowed to draw down the community. Therefore, respect for the paying members must be maintained by utilizing the tools available to enforce payment of delinquent assessments from the non-paying members. 

The normal process of collections requires a demand letter, a notification of intent to lien, the lien letter and the lien itself. Once the lien is recorded a Condo has up to a year to foreclose, while the Home Owners Association has 5 years. This provides for a unique position for the Association to work with the Unit Owner and to consider owner payment plan options before spending more money which it may have difficulty recovering. If this fails then the only recourse left is to file a lawsuit to foreclose the lien and ultimately sell the property.

My next series of posts will go into greater detail regarding payment plans and the actual foreclosure process.

• Email This
• Print
• Comments (4)
• Trackbacks
• Share Link